Warning: This multi-part series deals with the physical abuse of vulnerable children in the public school system. If you or someone you love is experiencing trauma-related symptoms from physical abuse, please seek help. Resources in Canada can be found here: https://www.canada.ca/en/public-health/services/health-promotion/stop-family-violence/services.html For children, Kids Help Phone: Call 1-800-668-6868 (toll-free) or text CONNECT to 686868.
On May 1, 2025, I went to the Yukon Legislative Assembly with my family, friends, and most importantly, the parents of victims of abuse from teachers at Jack Hulland Elementary. The remarkable team from the Yukon Child Youth Advocate Office was also in attendance.
Of note, we signed in as part of a contigent to witness the release of the Child and Youth Advocate Office Report on the abuse of children at Jack Hulland Elementary School in Whitehorse, Yukon. The Minister of Education would normally read our names as visitors, yet this job was given to one of her colleagues. The Minister of Education, Jeannie McLean, is also the Deputy Premier. She is a former student of Jack Hulland Elementary. Her riding includes families from Jack Hulland Elementary. She is responsible for enforcing the Education Act, which clearly prohibits corporal punishment in Yukon Schools.
In this post, I am sharing the words of the Child and Youth Advocate for the Yukon Territory. What follows is an excerpt from the report ” I Am Not Okay, It’s Not Okay”. The title comes from the favourite song of one of the Jack Hulland Elementary victims, a young man (“Max”) who died by suicide, directly related to what was done to him by educators at that school.
Advocate’s Message
This report has been a long time coming.
When YCAO first set out to do this review our primary focus was on trying to ensure that YG [Yukon Government] provided a coordinated response to the reports of abuse at JHES. We had no idea the magnitude of this situation, and we did not anticipate the toll it would take on all who were impacted, including our team.
As the investigations progressed, we observed a glaring gap in supports and so we undertook a job outside of our role as an oversight body, acting as a case coordinator – pushing for multi department meetings and ensuring appropriate referrals were made for the children harmed at JHES. In that acute time, our priority had to be providing individual advocacy directly for the children harmed at JHES who were referred to our office.
Since the dust has settled and the fault-finding investigations have concluded, we have been able to shift our focus back to the systemic review. Our goal with this review is to make sure that the families’ stories are told, and to evaluate YG’s response, providing recommendations so that this never happens again.
We have witnessed the alarming consequences of a systemic failure in the education system – one that has left vulnerable children subject to harmful practices, without accountability for those responsible.
The situation at JHES represents a glaring example of this failure, one that raises questions about the values and priorities of those who were entrusted with the care and development of Yukon children.
Educators who subscribe to the “Jack Hulland Way” argue that strict consequences are necessary for students, particularly those with behavioural challenges.
But the questions that remain unanswered are: Where are the consequences for the educators involved in harming these children? Where is the accountability for those whose actions and inactions inflicted lasting damage on young minds and bodies? Where is the accountability for those who were responsible to uphold EDU’s policies to keep students safe? Where is the accountability to repairing the harm and promoting recovery?
The silence around these questions is deafening. These children have been subjected to punitive and harmful measures, yet the individuals who imposed and condoned these measures face no consequences.
The investigations into the incidents at JHES have overlooked one of the most critical aspects – the impact on the children who endured, and in many cases, witnessed violence.
YCAO [Yukon Child and Youth Advocate Office] heard the stories from families and will endeavour to amplify their voices and promote their rights.
We won’t be part of keeping the silence.
We will make sure that the voices of those most affected by the incidents at JHES are not drowned out by the noise of institutional defense. Throughout the investigation, current and former staff members who expressed concerns and challenged the entrenched practices that defined the culture at JHES were reassigned or let go, raising issues of political interference.
As one parent observed, “the partisan politics, personal careers, and the remuneration of senior bureaucrats is coming at the expense of the education, safety, care, and welfare of children.”
This highlights the importance of transparency, accountability, and the need for deep systemic change. When the details began to emerge about the practices at JHES, many parents were unaware of the full extent of the punitive measures applied to their children, or of the escalating violence fostered by these approaches. What emerged was a troubling divide between staff – those who were deeply uncomfortable with the culture of physical restraint and confinement, and those who continued to embrace it. The division undermined the morale of educational staff and, more importantly, left children at the mercy of a system that failed to protect them.
From our observations, any lessons learned from former incidents regarding communication with families and providing timely therapeutic supports have not been applied to the situation at JHES. Instead, students have transferred out of JHES in search of a more welcoming and safe learning environment.
Despite efforts by the new leadership to change the culture, the building and many people in it proved too triggering for many students.
We want to elevate the voices of students, former students, and their families in the hope that their stories can drive real change.
Our most immediate concern is for the children who have been left behind in a system that seems more invested in maintaining a façade of normalcy than in addressing the deep harm that has been done.
These children deserve healing.
They deserve recovery.
They deserve an education system that does not disengage them from school and community but instead embraces them with the care and respect they so deeply need.
When harm is inflicted, it is not enough to simply move on.
The children who have suffered, as well as their families, deserve not only answers but also a commitment to healing.
This report aims to bring some level of accountability, to bring transparency to a system that has failed to protect those who were most vulnerable, and to ensure that no child is ever again subjected to the practices that have caused such profound harm.
Annette King
Yukon Child and Youth Advocate
Resources:
I Am Not Okay, It’s Not Okay: https://www.ycao.ca/_files/ugd/a5713e_d42f42a1de544c8c9dd67bbcff9e8b24.pdf
Hansard, May 1, 2025 Yukon Legislative Assembly https://yukonassembly.ca/sites/default/files/hansard/35-1-255.pdf
The Kids of Jack Hulland Elementary – In Progress
- Introduction
- Timeline Part 1 (Class Action Lawsuit)
- Timeline Part 2 (RCMP)
- Section 43 of the Criminal Code of Canada
- The Statement of Claim
- The Yukon Child and Youth Advocate’s Office
- The [Missing] Kids of Jack Hulland Elementary
- Week 1 Summary
- The Federal NDP Attempt to Repeal Section 43 of the Criminal Code of Canada (Bill C-273)
- UPDATE: Bill C-273
- UPDATE: Supreme Court of Yukon Decision March 27, 2024
- UPDATE: Yukon Child and Youth Advocate’s Office PODCAST
- No Pain, No Shame, No Blame (American Academy of Paediatrics)
- I Am Not Okay, It’s Not Okay (Report on the Systemic Use of Holds, Restraints and Isolation at Jack Hulland Elementary School – May 1, 2025)
- Senator Stan Kutcher and Bill S-251 to Repeal Section 43
- Truth and Reconciliation Call to Action 6
- The Rights of Children
- The Public Education System in the Yukon
- Ronald Morrish – Discipline that Harms
- Ethical Practice and the Teaching Profession
- Recap and FAQ
- Childhood Trauma – ACES – Introduction (more to follow)
- The long-term impact of physical abuse of children
- What we know about corporal punishment of children
Class Action Lawsuit: Were you (or someone you know) a student at Jack Hulland Elementary School in Whitehorse, Yukon during the years 2007 to 2022? You may be entitled to compensation as part of a class action lawsuit against the Yukon Department of Education. Please contact Tucker-Carruthers Yukon Law for more information. Website: https://tuckercarruthers.ca/ or contact Heather Jordan, Paralegal at 867-667-2099 or email hjordan@yukonlaw.com
Who I Am: My name is Donna Miller Fry. I was Superintendent of Schools in Whitehorse, Yukon when I became aware that prior to my arrival, children at Jack Hulland Elementary School were being restrained and secluded as a method of discipline – for years. I (and others) reported this to the RCMP on November 29, 2021. Since then, the Department of Education has admitted the inappropriate use of restraints and seclusion. The victims have resorted to legal action to obtain professional support in addressing the impacts of trauma. This can never happen again in the public school system. By telling this story, I hope to empower education leaders to ensure vulnerable children are never again the victims of abuse in the very place that should be dedicated to their flourishing.
